« Despite the Institution | Main | The Day I Preached from the Pope's Chair »

Games Ministers Play

pastor.jpgI was having a long chat last night with a younger brother of mine who’s in training for the full-time ministry. The basic essence of the discussion rested upon the reality that few people today understand the most fundamental functions of a minister, which are to conduct the sacraments (together with living the incarnational / sacramental life) and to preach the authentic gospel of Christ. Even senior pastors; they’re most often taken in by church growth models and programmes focused on acquisition and retention.


The model of ministry has evolved uncritically. A pastor is now gauged by how effective he is in managing a church which propels around programmes and systems. The pastor is consciously seen as coordinator, manager, and organiser; everything but the sacramental presence of Christ among his people.


Accordingly, my advice to this brother (as it is for all my students in the seminary) was that full time ministerial work is worth it only if one has the guts to stake one’s income, future, reputation, career and security upon one’s convictions. As we enter the said vocation, the immediate expectations of our “employers” would be to run programmes, attend meetings, write reports, and perhaps, occasionally preach good sermons. If we have no inkling of our mission in this vocation and rely on a job description prescribed by others, we’ll find ourselves simply doing what others do in the corporate sector, but receiving half or a third of the income they get. Being in this vocation is worth it only if we have the guts to say “no” and to abide by a divinely prescribed role for the minister… and to risk losing it all.


As a very young minister in training in my early twenties, I was abruptly thrown off when I was given this piece of advice by an elder whom I’d looked up to prior to that occasion: “You have potential, you can become somebody. All you need to do is learn to play the game well.” As a very young hot-blooded minister, I answered in utter defiance, “If I wanted to, I could play a better game than you do, but I’m not interested in your games.”


Unfortunately, after some eight years of being in ministry full time, I’ve realised that this elder was right. And perhaps he was simply observing a reality which I myself now observe to be true. Just like any other corporate institution, the minister finds himself having potential to rise to high positions when he establishes “relations” and plays by the rules of the game. Some (not all!) of those who do it best eventually rise to become denominational leaders.


To be true ministers of the gospel, the only way to go is to be at peace with the idea of being a nobody for the rest of our lives. We shouldn't resort to playing games in the name of "calling". If we want to kiss ass and climb the ladder, might as well go do it in the corporate sector and be paid two or three times the amount.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.shermankuek.net/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/390

Comments (6)

Can be true in a lot of churches, but there are also some denominational leaders who are very godly and sincere. I guess its not the people involved, but may be the "system" we are in? If that is true, that is the biggest challenge we have: how to change the "system" or culture to a more godly and authentically Christian culture. And I am just talking about within the church.

sherman, thanks for this. what a great reminder for those of us who are pastors and are tempted to sell out and play the game.

Sherman, I think in general you are right, but the difficult thing is to remember that often (though certainly not always) if we live by integrity in humility, God will often use us and put in us in greater positions of responsibility. Consider Jacob, who never complained, yet eventually and after much suffering became a leader in Egypt. This certainly should not be our motivation for humilty, but it should be a reminder to us that all is not hopeless.

I guess "seek first..." and "he who is faithful with a little..." are the two principles to keep in mind.

I agree with your post, but don't want to forget that God uses those who are faithful. Sometimes as denominational leaders, and sometimes as simple pastors in tiny churches that have a great impact.

Hi Sherman,

I am obviously not in vocational ministry but the same principles would probably apply for us working within the social advocacy and non-profit sector; especially here in Malaysia.

Good food for thought.

Cheers,

Bob K

A pastor or elder's primary role is to preach the Word of God and to pray. It may be difficult not to play the game which offers so much immediate affirmation, gratification and honour. But that is not what you are here for. Listen to God's calling on your life and follow.

Shalom.

My ministry experience ranges from "part-time" college ministry with a couple of small (but happy) congregations, to a church planting mission in Brazil, to a "full-time" ministry position with an American church. The first two were wonderful. The last was a nightmare. I can't be a CEO. Now I'm bivocational and doing the best I can to support my family while recovering from that bad experience. Only now, after nearly two years, am I getting back into active ministry. I can't see myself dependent on a congregation for my full support again. It's not a game for me.

Post a comment

Sherman YL Kuek


TwitterLogo.JPG
LIVE UPDATES from Sherman


FollowShermanOnTwitter.jpg

FollowShermanOnFacebook.jpg




SHERMAN'S SHUFFLES

CRUCIAL CATEGORIES

VALIANT VOICES

StPetertheApostle.jpg StPaul.JPG CappadocianFathers.jpg Augustine.jpg Chrysostom.jpg Aquinas.jpg FrancisofAssisi.jpg MotherTeresa.jpg JohnPaulII.jpg Benedictus.jpg


Sherman's Seal (No Background).jpg


thinkingblogger2ql6.jpg





Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence.