Christian Cliches
This is a further reflection from Alwyn's post on how Christians often advance cliches like "Trust God" and hope you buy into what they're saying. I agree with Alwyn.
I think the easiest way to shake someone off (who's facing a complication in life) and still remain untainted in one's conscience is by spewing something spiritual like "Trust God" and "I'll pray for you". And then, to deceive yourself into thinking that you've somehow been part of the solution to this person's problem. It's false spirituality and has nothing to do with fulfilling the rule to love God and your neighbour.
When is saying "Trust God" or "I'll pray for you" appropriate? It's appropriate when:
1. You've actually wasted your time sitting down and listening to your friend's problem and trying to understand his situation. This is so that you have actually taken the time to care to know the magnitude of the problem without presumptuously thinking you have anything valuable to offer in terms of solutions.
2. You've actually found it within the recesses of your heart and mind to care for the wellbeing of this person. In other words, when you can tell yourself that you love this person or have made a choice to do so. And so, listening to this person isn't just something you do as a Christian duty. Because it isn't a Christian duty to listen. It's a Christian duty to love. And if you listen, listen because you love.
3. You're actually determined to be a proactive companion to this person in his journey towards seeking solutions. By this, it doesn't mean you must be the solution itself. You just have to be a companion to this person as he journeys towards seeking solutions. And together with that, be willing to stake your own resources to contribute towards the solution - yes, I'm talking about time, money, effort, and anything else.
If not, don't flippantly say "Trust God" or "I'll pray for you", please... it's downright pretentious. It's religious, but pretentious.







Comments (5)
I agree. The cliche I am always careful of is "I'll pray for you" because I realise I always ending up not doing so. Therefore, I make it a point to say it sparingly and try to make sure that I do. But sometimes, one or two still sneak itself through.
Posted by pearlie | January 25, 2007 6:15 PM
amen, bro, amen to what you wrote.
Posted by Alex Tang | January 25, 2007 9:21 PM
not only that, even to say "i understand.." is also pretentious. there is absolutely NO WAY at all someone could understand what the other is going through unless they've really been through the same situation.
Posted by peiling | January 26, 2007 11:25 AM
sk and sk again - such clarity for conscientising and casting out the religious spirit.
Posted by luke | January 26, 2007 11:42 AM
my post was done in a spirit of anger, yours done in love - good man, :)
Posted by alwyn | January 26, 2007 2:36 PM